Heating Oil Prices in Bryn Athyn, PA
Today $5.94/gallon for 100 gallons, across 2 local dealers. Order online — no waiting for a callback to get a price.
Prices updated today at 2:23 pm. We never show a rate you can’t actually get.
See every price for Bryn Athyn
Enter your ZIP — 19009 — and compare all dealers side by side.
Bryn Athyn is a borough of a few hundred households above the Pennypack, and an unusual one: it was built around the Academy of the New Church, and the cathedral, Glencairn and the Academy buildings are the reason most people have heard of it. A quarter of its homes heat with oil.
Neighborhoods we deliver to in Bryn Athyn
- Bryn Athyn
How our trucks get here
Deliveries into Bryn Athyn run off Huntingdon Pike and Byberry Road.
Long private drives are the norm rather than the exception here, and several are gated or shared. Huntingdon Pike is the way in and out for almost everything. If the tank fill is round the back or the drive is steep, say so on the order — on lots this size it makes a real difference to how the driver plans the stop.
Local landmarks
- Bryn Athyn Church
- Glencairn Museum
- the Academy of the New Church
- Bryn Athyn Academy
- the Swedenborg Library
- Alnwick Grove
- Burrow Park
Tanks in Bryn Athyn homes
A small borough with a lot of stone: substantial older houses on generous lots, a good number of them associated with the Academy, and comparatively little later infill. Cellars throughout. The 275 is common, though a house of this age and size may well take a 550 — worth checking before a fill rather than after.
Bryn Athyn by the numbers
25.5%
of the 349 households in ZIP 19009 heat with oil — 89 homes.
- Population
- 1,153
- Households
- 349
- Land area
- 1.3 sq mi
- Median household income
- $142k
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2019–2023 American Community Survey 5-year estimates, and the 2023 ZCTA Gazetteer. ZIP Code Tabulation Areas approximate postal ZIPs and don’t follow municipal boundaries, so these describe the ZIP rather than the borough or township exactly.
Buying heating oil in Bryn Athyn
Bryn Athyn is 89 of 349 households on oil, about 25.5% — roughly one house in four. It is also one of only four Montgomery County ZIPs we serve where ordering more genuinely costs less per gallon: the 150 and 200-gallon bands price below the 100-gallon band, where most ZIPs around here are flat across those volumes. On a house that takes a 550, that is worth knowing before you order. Prices move daily with the wholesale rack, which is why the number above is today’s and not last week’s. Local dealers compete on this page, so the lowest price is always at the top — we don’t sell placement above a better price.
How much oil do you need in Bryn Athyn?
Order a dollar amount, a number of gallons, or ask for a fill — whichever way you actually think about it. Tell us your tank size and what the gauge reads and we’ll warn you before you pay if the tank won’t take it all. You’re charged only for the gallons that actually go in, and if it takes less, your price per gallon doesn’t go up.
Heating oil in Bryn Athyn — common questions
Do you deliver heating oil in Bryn Athyn, PA?+
Yes, to 19009. Huntingdon Valley next door is 19006 and Southampton is 18966 — both also served, each on its own ZIP.
Why does Bryn Athyn have so much more oil heat than the townships around it?+
About 25.5% of homes here burn oil, 89 of 349. A small borough of large older houses on big lots never made the case for running gas down every road that a dense subdivision does, and the housing stock has changed very little.
Does a bigger delivery actually cost less per gallon in Bryn Athyn?+
Yes, and that is uncommon around here. In 19009 the 150 and 200-gallon bands are priced below the 100-gallon band. Only four of the Montgomery County ZIPs we serve do that — most are flat across those volumes — so it is worth reading the ladder here rather than assuming either way.
I have a 550 and a long drive. Can you still deliver?+
Yes — both are common here. Tell us the tank size and anything awkward about the approach when you order. A 550 taking a full fill is a bigger drop than most, which is exactly where the volume bands are worth using.
Can I order a small top-up in Bryn Athyn?+
Yes, 19009 has a 50-gallon band. It is dearer per gallon than 100 gallons, because the trip costs the same whatever comes off the truck, so it suits an emergency rather than a routine fill.
Also in Bryn Athyn: oil burner tune-ups, chimney cleaning and automatic delivery.